Collegium clears 9 names for appointment as SC judges, 3 women on the list
New Delhi, August 18, 2021
Ending the nearly two-year-long deadlock, the Supreme Court Collegium, headed by Chief Justice N. V. Ramana and comprising four senior most judges, is learnt to have recommended nine names for appointment to the top court.
Supreme Court judge Justice Navin Sinha is set to retire on Wednesday, which will leave 10 vacancies out of 34 in the top court.
According to sources familiar with the development, out of these 10 vacancies, the collegium has zeroed in on nine names. There has been no appointment after September 2019.
The list of recommendations includes three women judges, including B. V. Nagarathna from the Karnataka High Court who, if elevated now, could become the country's first woman CJI in February 2027 and occupy the post until October 29, 2027, for 8 months. Justice Nagarathna would succeed Justice Surya Kant as CJI in February 2027. Justice Nagarathna's father, Justice E.S. Venkataramiah, had served as the CJI for a few months in 1989.
Chief Justice Ramana's predecessor Chief Justice S. A. Bobde did not make a single appointment during his 17-month tenure, as he couldn't build a consensus on several names, which stalled appointments in the top court.
The other two women judges selected by the collegium are Justice Hima Kohli, who is the chief justice of Telangana HC, and justice Bela Trivedi, who is a judge in the Gujarat High Court. Senior advocate P. S. Narasimha is the collegium's choice for direct appointment to the bench. Narasimha's recommendation has come nearly a week after the retirement of justice Rohinton F. Nariman, who was the fifth lawyer to be directly appointed from the bar.
Other names finalised by the collegium are: justice Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, chief justice of Karnataka High Court; Vikram Nath, chief justice of Gujarat High Court; justice Jitendra Kumar Maheshwari, chief justice of Sikkim High Court; justice C.T. Ravikumar, judge in Kerala HC; and justice M.M. Sundresh, judge in Kerala High Court.
The source added that these recommendations have been sent to the Law Ministry, which has the option of sending the recommendations back to the collegium for review. However, if these recommendations are re-submitted by the collegium, then the names have to be approved.
According to sources, the impasse in the collegium persisted due to Justice Nariman's firm stand over recommending Justice Akil A Kureshi, currently chief justice of the Tripura high court, as a judge in the apex court.
Currently, the top court has only one woman judge, Justice Indira Banerjee, who is set to retire in September 2022. There have only been eight women judges appointed in the Supreme Court till date.